Editorial comments from Chasing Nonconformity (Part 1)

I am happy to announce that my editor (i.e. my mother) has returned the latest draft of Chasing Nonconformity back to me, full of comments and ready for revisions! Upon going through said comments, I found some of them quite amusing, and thought I might share them with you here today. This is part 1 of the images — part 2 will be posted tomorrow — so make sure to come back and see the second half of her excellent and insightful commentary. Also make sure to check out the caption on each photo for context.

Without further ado …

[SPOILER ALERT] The following images contain snippets of text from the Chasing Nonconformity manuscript. Don’t scroll down if you don’t like spoilers!

1403100359594

Mother kindly illustrates a scene for me in order to demonstrate … something.

1403100702299

Mother gets sassy.

1403100977379

Mother gives me her life story at the start of chapter 3.

1403101038480

Mother illustrates her current editing situation.

1403101398140

Mother gets sassy, and then explains the sudden and alarming switch in pen color.

1403101490070

Mother gets really excited about a furniture store upon a mention in the text of Swedish meatballs.

1403101565449

Mother takes issue with my description of a room.

1403102825745

Mother is alarmed by flying eyebrows.

1403102891672

Mother illustrates an awkward water situation.

Advertisements
Categories: My Works, Self Publishing, Writing | Tags: , , , , , , , | 30 Comments

Post navigation

30 thoughts on “Editorial comments from Chasing Nonconformity (Part 1)

  1. Oh, your mother is hilarious. I bet life never got boring growing up. 🙂 Lucky you, Michelle, to have such a cool mom. Good luck with your revisions.

    • Haha no, life certainly never got boring. It got extremely confusing at times, and sometimes cringe-worthingly embarrassing, but never boring! Thanks for the luck — definitely going to need it 🙂

  2. The Pina Colada picture is my favourite, looking forward to part II.

  3. I love the comments! Does she take commissioned work?

    Even more than sassy mom, I love the sketches (although I envisioned Eris somewhat cuter, I have to admit)! 🙂

    • Ha! She barely has enough time in her day to call me, let alone read my books … let alone take commissions! Although I bet if you paid her enough … 😀

  4. She must know the rocket scientist. They have the same color pen. it is so much nicer than red, I think 🙂 Too funny. I want to see those eyebrows fly skyward.

    • Haha. You may yet see eyebrows flying skyward — I’m pretty sure I had that phrase in there a couple of times, and I don’t think mom caught all of them.

  5. Even though I’m not around much right now, I couldn’t resist this post when it showed up in my email. What a way to start my day – with a smile on my face. Your mother is fantastic. Those are the type of edits everyone would love to have!

    • Haha. Of course, I left out all the comments about “this doesn’t make any sense”, “this sentence is awkward”, “why would she do this?” etc. But there were a few gems in there, which I pulled out just for you 😀 Glad you enjoyed them!

  6. Skies above, I wish I had an editor like this!

    • I can loan her to you, although it’s a family rate, so we’d have to adopt you in order for you to acquire her services 😀

  7. I may have to learn to draw—your mom’s edits are a riot!

    • Lol, I like that — “a riot”. Excellent way to describe them. Also, I’m pretty sure you don’t need much in the way of drawing lessons in order to reach my mother’s level of artistic skill 😀

    • And you thought you knew all the copy editing symbols, Candace.

  8. That was hilarious. The joys of editors with sass and drawing ability. 🙂

  9. Gwen Stephens

    Now I understand where your airy brand of humor comes from 🙂

  10. Oh gosh! I have an old story I wrote in 6th grade, and I wish someone like your mother had gone through and given me doodle-critiques on certain things… Like how the main character could crawl like 7 miles with a broke leg in a day, and then take like a week to travel the same distance on horseback. :I

  11. Pingback: Editorial comments from Chasing Nonconformity (Part 2) | Michelle Proulx - The Blog

  12. Jo Svensson

    Reblogged this on and so the story goes and commented:
    One of my favourite parts of writing – the reader response! Here with some amusing examples from Michelle Proulx’s trusted reader, her mother.

  13. Excellent stuff! Love the little drawings. Thanks for sharing. Wish I had these on my manuscript edits – makes editing much less tedious!

  14. I wish ALL editors had such a sense of humor 🙂

    • Well, keep in mind that I only shared the funny comments, lol. There were lots of “this doesn’t make sense”, “you need to change this entire chapter”, “Character X is acting completely insane — rewrite”, etc. But the funny ones sort of make up for it 🙂

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: